The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency has improved its incident reporting form, and the changes are sensible. The revised questionnaire asks more granular questions about whether an incident involved malware, social engineering, hacking techniques or an insider threat. It also describes observed activity using MITRE ATT&CK, a framework that CISA says is familiar to the cyber community. Better structured data should make it easier for the agency to connect related activity that might otherwise look like separate incidents. That is a real gain for national defense.
The problem is the gap between what the form can do and what the law requires. Right now only federal civilian agencies must report incidents to CISA. Everyone else reports voluntarily, and the agency's own announcement did not mention the Cyber Incident Reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act or whether the new form would be used under the pending rule. A richer form that few organizations are obligated to use will produce richer data only from the organizations that already choose to share it.
The final CIRCIA rule has been waiting for approval since it went to the White House for review on October 1, and it is still listed as pending. CISA published its proposed rule in April 2024 and missed an October 2025 statutory deadline to finalize it. Under the proposal, covered critical infrastructure organizations would have to report qualifying incidents within 72 hours of reasonably believing they occurred, and ransom payments within 24 hours. Those are the requirements that would turn voluntary goodwill into a dependable national picture.
Commenters on the proposal asked for a narrower scope, less burden and closer alignment with other federal reporting rules. Those requests are reasonable, and the agency should weigh them seriously. Narrowing the rule does not have to mean weakening it. A clearer scope can make compliance easier for companies and reporting more consistent for the government. But every month of delay leaves the reporting regime split between a mandatory system for federal civilian agencies and a voluntary one for everyone else.
CISA should publish a clear statement tying its new form to the CIRCIA rule, including what data it will collect from covered entities once the rule takes effect. It should also finish the final rule and set a firm timeline for its approval. The agency's own leader said incident reporting helps identify emerging campaigns and warn potential targets. That promise is only fully realized when reporting is mandatory for the organizations most exposed to attack.