The New York City Council's 44-5 vote to bar businesses from using personal data to charge different people different prices for the same product is a meaningful step. Mayor Zohran Mamdani put the stakes plainly: "when corporations use your personal data to decide what you pay, you only stand to lose." That is the right way to frame the issue, and the city deserves credit for acting before the practice is fully entrenched.
The bill's design is sensible in several respects. It lets the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection fine violators up to $1,000 per violation, which gives the ban teeth. It also carves out "bona fide discounts and rewards that are legitimate and transparent," such as buy-one-get-one-free deals, loyalty programs and discounts for veterans and students. That distinction matters. Shoppers should not lose the ordinary savings that transparent promotions provide, and the line between a public offer and a hidden, individualized price is the line regulators need to police.
Still, the report makes clear how much remains unknown. Grocery stores, ride-sharing companies and airlines are thought to use surveillance pricing, but public evidence is limited. Kroger has denied the charges even as Consumer Reports has documented its tracking and data sales. The Federal Trade Commission has sent orders to nine companies, including Uber, DoorDash, Walmart and Target, and says it wants to study the "opaque methodology" behind pricing. Lawmakers are legislating against a practice that outsiders can barely see, which is precisely why disclosure requirements and enforcement capacity should be treated as part of the ban, not afterthoughts.
The state picture is also uncertain. New York's legislature passed a similar law in June, yet it has sat unsigned on Gov. Kathy Hochul's desk for months, and advocates worry she could use a state statute to weaken its language. Governor Hochul should sign the bill as passed. A city ban cannot fully protect eight million residents if state law is hollowed out, and businesses operating across the state will be watching which version becomes binding.
Other jurisdictions should take the same lesson. New Jersey, Connecticut and Maryland already have bans, and more legislators are expected to act when new sessions begin. Consumers have a simple complaint: they are being sized up for how much they will pay, and the anonymity that once protected them is gone. Lawmakers should respond with clear rules, real penalties and enforceable transparency requirements.